Hmmmph. Biased? Okay....
Anyways, I'm pretty sure I told both Ichirou and Shadow that I was going to be away for a week on vacation so I wouldn't be able to constantly check in and work on their never ending issues. If I recall, once Trev was booted as the initial judge and his ruling seemed 'unjust/biased/unfair/you don't like it' I was appointed judge, yippee! >>; Now that I've made a ruling the same process undergoes? That seems odd.
Skepticism aside, I'll explain my own thought on this predicament. Once we solved the previous dispute about FTG and escaping the fight all together and making Shadow chase him, Ichirou accepted the fact that Shadow's Kamui attempt was a success. With that alone, the next scene follows through with Ichirou's entire person being warped into this Kamui realm. From then on, Ichi messaged me a couple times and proposed his plan of escaping one realm by going into the other, allowing him to escape the Kamui as well as return to the 'human realm' I'll call it that. From that alone I was iffy to give my opinion on such, especially without my own knowledge if such were to be possible in the naruto verse. It was literally one word over the other at that point. Honestly I figured something as simple as reverse summon could work; yet the whole idea of opening up a separate realm, while already within a separate realm, to return to the realm he was once on seemed a little too far fetched for me to believe. I still want no part in said discussion since it stops being about naruto and more about space time continuum and dimensions and stuff, too complicated.
Either way, I was told to make a decision on the match entirely. Seeing as how it finished with Shadow successfully being able to get Ichirou into his Kamui dimension, that awarded Shadow 'points' if there was a score to be kept. Now with that aside, the fight seemed to have ended, no matter what. The point being that Ichirou's tactics went from battle-mode, to escape-mode. It was no longer a fight per say, but 'what tactic should I use to escape this defeat'. I'm sorry, but there was no other way for me to put it. It stopped being about defending yourself and it went into retreating/evading and that alone signified an end to this battle in my eyes. Maybe instead of just escaping he had some sort of retaliation in his sleeve while also fleeing the assault, the battle could continue on! But that was never the case I saw, nor see. So yes. In an overall decision, miles away from my own home and barely logged onto SL, I told Shadow that I had felt he won this match. Yet I NEVER said it was over with. I allow for both participants a fighting chance, Ichirou still has one but from the look of his sticky situation, I didn't feel like he would be able to overcome Shadow's last attack with this new one so suddenly and conveniently. He still has options but I am opposed to this whole realm-ception going on.