So here's the point that you're currently contesting:
A challenger finally discovers the identity and location of a Jinchūriki. Said challenger then goes to location. Finds out that a village is in the way. One of two options presents itself: (logically and ICcly) Is the challenger strong enough to wipe out further completion and then fight the jinch? If not, then (s)he seeks entrance into the village like a *gasp!* ninja and seek out the Jinchūriki.
From there, and only there, would a fight 1v1 be *forced* despite the parameters of being in the village. At that point, I would say the Jinchūriki would recognize that the threat the challenger poses to his/her beloved village and takes the fight elsewhere. (S)He also demands the village to NOT interfere in the fight until a victor has emerged, one way or the other. If it is the Jinchūriki, then yes, parade around with the corpse and revel in your victory. If it's the challenger, well, you better learn how to get the hell of dodge if you're still trapped in the village.
That is how the situation pans out. Just like how it does for Itachi and Kisame canonically. They couldn't overpower the Leaf Jōnin and got the hell out while they still could. *Gasp!* Then they came back for another shot that was opportunistic to them...
Technically Jiraiya (legendary sannin, no mere jounin) sent the two scurrying, but other than that yeah, I guess it is not too much to ask that the challengers at least
try to be sneaky about it.
Be that as it may, this:
The host and the challenger, and ONLY the host and challenger, determine the nature of the challenge. BOTH decide if the match will be an IC Challenge or an OOC Challenge. This means that if an IC Challenge is chosen, the challenger has to RP learning the host’s identity and location and maneuvers him into a Match. This does not mean that the RP is used as a means for the Host to forever avoid having to face his challenger. The host must make it possible for the challenger to complete the terms of the RP event. This is not the battle part. You are going to face off with each other. You are just being creative about it.
If the OOC Challenge is chosen, then no RP concerning the challenge is performed. The details are agreed upon and the Match takes place.
Can probably be changed to something more along these lines:
The host and the challenger, and ONLY the host and challenger, determine the nature of the challenge. BOTH decide if the match will be an IC Challenge or an OOC Challenge.
The host is required to accept the challenge, presuming the judge has found neither party having run afoul. Whether the battle takes place in the area or not is determined by the challenger's and host's RP initially.
If the host offers to take the battle outside of a village and/or area populated with other human players and the challenger refuses (or does not give the host the opportunity by surprise attacking them) then the host may call upon any other players on the RP board to come to their aide if necessary. In all other cases, only the previously agreed upon number of participants (whether it 1v1 or 4v4) may participate in the ensuing battle. The agreed upon judge and the rules of biju matches have final say on all matters of disagreement between challenger and challenged.
If there are no restrictions on the number of participants, then the challenger must, as before, have knowledge of who the host of the beast is and enter the village and/or area that the host is in. However, they are not required to directly challenge the host in person, and may be subject to a village battle (if that is the setting) or other such actions from the host's village if they decide to engage recklessly. Since there are no restrictions on the number of participants, then both challenger and host can call in as much assistance as required once the fighting begins. What consists of "the fight" and "the hunt" is up to the judge if there is a discrepancy, but in general, "the hunt" is finding and challenging the host while "the fight" is the battle between challenger and host to determine the fate of the tailed beast.
If the OOC Challenge is chosen, then no RP concerning the challenge is performed. The details are agreed upon and the Match takes place.
There is ABSOLUTELY NO RP involved with an OOC challenge.Additionally, taking a look at this:
1] ºHow to Challenge a Jinchurikiº
In order to challenge a Jinchuriki & obtain a Biju, one must extend an invitation to its host; this places you on the list of challengers that each host must update in a publicly accessibly spot. [Either as a post in this thread or on the wikia as a discussion topic on the tailed beasts page. Here] The two will make all arrangements for when the match will begin and where. Should the Jinchuriki ignore or refuse the invitation(s)-with no reason given- 3 times consecutively, you may report it to other Jinchuriki. Subject for such an event's invitation, for proof & reference of a challenge, must be titled: (Number of tails) - (Name of Jinchuriki); the body of the message may be as you please (though manners & politeness would of course make things much smoother).
We should clarify (in accordance with the new proposal):
1] ºHow to Challenge a Jinchurikiº
If the fight is OOC (Out of Character), then a challenger must extend a formal invitiation (PM's, posts, whatever, make sure there is a record of it). The host then adds the challenger to the list, and the two begin working on details for the match.
If the fight is IC (In Character) then the challenger and/or party must make an attempt to enter into the host village, learn the host's identity, and issue the challenge directly to the jinchurikii in person. This is to be done with the intent to fight/provoke only the host (and agreed upon support if necessary. The jinchurikii must be directly approached and challenged in person, face-to-face. All actions pertaining to the challenge, except for the selection of a judge, must be done in character.
No demanding to fight the jinch outside of the jinch's presence or otherwise giving the village a reason to attack the challenging party in a challenge with participant restrictions.
Violations either by host (metagaming or otherwise encouraging the challenger's party attacked without seeming provocation, intentionally hiding to prevent the challenger from directly encountering them for an extended period of time (week IC time), etc.) or challenger (belligerently demanding to see the jinchurikii for the sake of fighting them or provoking the townspeople otherwise) will result in the appointed judge making a call on whether either or both have run afoul of the conditions of the match.
If the judge finds the jinchurikii guilty, a strip order may be placed,or the offending action rectified. if the judge finds the challenger guilty, revocation of challenger privileges (no immunity from being attacked in a match with limited participants for example) or the offending action voided and the attempt restarted. These are at the judge's discretion as to reduce bickering.
Other adjustments too can be made, but the main one I think iss making the judge decider not just in the fight itself, but in the hunts as well, in order to nip arguments more swiftly in the bud.
Author
Topic: Get Rid of Biju Rules? Or are major amendments the better route? (Read 16299 times)