Roleplay > Council

Should Council Members Judge Biju Matches? VOTE

(1/4) > >>

UettoSenju:
I saw this question or idea arise some. I think the title is self explanatory.

*****************************
I would have to say no.

Simply for the reason that as a council member they will have to place judgment on the actions of breaking rules concerning those which are placed forward from whatever is provided, I presume. I think that by judging a match, which is based on the judgment of rp not the rules of the system, may lead to a more bais outcome in the later. For example if the rp judge has a hard time dealing with his/her judgment being accepted and is pounded or slandered due to such it may lead to them passing judgment on the council side of things in a negative way as to seek revenge or some other ill felt feelings.

Court:
No. I've provided enough reason already. Leave out any biased opinion.

Ace:
No.

Camel:
No. That judge should be chosen from the community and that choice of *judge* should be agree upon by both parties.

KayentaMoenkopi:
No.

the judge should be participant chosen, but NOT a council member.

It is important to have them outside all things bijuu as much as possible. If they are judges, bad feelings toward them could form due to rulings that are unpopular. We need the rule enforcers to be accepted by the community so the rules will be followed and strife will calm down.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page