Shinobi Legends Forum
Roleplay => Village Square => Topic started by: Ѕhadow on July 17, 2014, 04:23:15 AM
-
So if we're really going with this community decided thing...here's the first part of that. These GM's will not have in-game powers, but will more or less be Judges unless Neji does decide to get involved and give them such powers.
For case one.... I'd like to vote Darkshinobi in as a judge/GM. While he has been missing from the rp scene at times (we all have) he has always came back and as of lately, active. Every day and he does interact in rp and comments on these topics. He has shown considerable knowledge of the rp mechanics and to my belief is one of the best at analytics. (I love using that word it seems).
I could keep going on and on like it's a recommendation letter, but just my voice alone won't set it in stone. So...this topic is to induct Darkshinobi as a judge/GM. Not by the staff or Neji. If you need a judge this person will come to be that judge in an unbiased and fair manner taking no sides. Comments, thoughts, anything?
I'll open a poll like always cause I think they're fun. xD
-
Notes that I am sure if you ask Dark to be a judge he will be. Just to point that out and he is a rather good one at that.
I also would like to start judging so stuff as well. My record for such things is pretty good. Never had any complaints. I don't feel much like rping these days so it would be something I'd be interested in.
As to the topic yeah Dark is a good judge. Although, I wouldn't call him a GM unless made so by the staff.
-
I think it is a good idea to ask our peers to look at things and give their opinions. When WE fail to handle our disputes ourselves.
HOWEVER....if you do ask someone to come help you, please be nice if they do not give the answer you want. I tell you what....IF people start getting nasty with Dark for not handing down the judgement they wish and they make him quit here I am handing out head thumpings to every one involved.
The players involved pick and agree on a judge to handle a dispute. If someone doesn't agree with the decision made after then they're shit out of luck. They agreed on the judge. No redos.
-
I think it is a good idea to ask our peers to look at things and give their opinions. When WE fail to handle our disputes ourselves.
HOWEVER....if you do ask someone to come help you, please be nice if they do not give the answer you want. I tell you what....IF people start getting nasty with Dark for not handing down the judgement they wish and they make him quit here I am handing out head thumpings to every one involved.
The players involved pick and agree on a judge to handle a dispute. If someone doesn't agree with the decision made after then they're shit out of luck. They agreed on the judge. No redos.
That's pretty much the way it should be.
Also it is smart to always publicly post the conditions to your fight people. That way later there isn't an argument about what was agreed upon. Just throwing that out there.... pretty much why I always make an OOC post before things letting all know what is happening.
-
Well it's not the way it is though. Look at Kiri. 3 separate judges were called in for the very same issue. I personally was smeared as being biased and name called because I didn't side with that person.
A different time a ruling was handed out through arbitration. I had each person make concessions to the other and they were in agreement, then one party decided to just negate that.
I do agree that pre-game conditions are a good thing. That seems to work well. When who you are rping with is reasonable.
After all of that we removed Bocc and Dart from the rp. They were the main issue. Now gone. Isa and I are leading the teams in terms of not arguing, which I am against arguing anymore on all fronts. I'll debate, but that's it.
The judges worked, but there were just too many issues being complained about for anyone to deal with.
-
Yeah in multi person fights it causes an issue.
I talked with Kay and Warren with Shadowfire about his one post and we got a decision, then it was Dart's post next and he wanted to argue about something that was part of the decision.
So what then? Do I need to get another judge to make a decision on the decision for each person I am fighting against in a village rp?
Good to know I was part of the problem by being the target of Dart's flaming though.
-
Yeah in multi person fights it causes an issue.
I talked with Kay and Warren with Shadowfire about his one post and we got a decision, then it was Dart's post next and he wanted to argue about something that was part of the decision.
So what then? Do I need to get another judge to make a decision on the decision for each person I am fighting against in a village rp?
Good to know I was part of the problem by being the target of Dart's flaming though.
I don't have an answer for when people like Dart show up. Maybe someone else does. However there's not many on SL who act like Dart either.
-
Well it's not the way it is though. Look at Kiri. 3 separate judges were called in for the very same issue. I personally was smeared as being biased and name called because I didn't side with that person.
A different time a ruling was handed out through arbitration. I had each person make concessions to the other and they were in agreement, then one party decided to just negate that.
I do agree that pre-game conditions are a good thing. That seems to work well. When who you are rping with is reasonable.
That's because people these days are little whinny asses. Really it seems the older we grow (considering how long we all have been here) the more immature the mass number becomes.
It's a game people... you loss time to time. Deal with it. Failing is apart of life it forces you to grow and correct yourself. You become stronger by failing more than succeeding.
Of course, there are those who will still pout when things don't go their way. That is why the majority of use need to just show tough love and be like, "Look the judge said this. You agreed to this judge. This is how it will be. Or we can just ignore you as a mass effect on the site rp wish sense you fail to want to play nice and reasonable."
You know if people start getting along again you may just find that fighting and all that jazz is pretty fun. Hell I'll take Bocc and me for example. We can duke it out in character and talk OOC like best buds simultaneously. Why? Because we respect each other I think.
Same as when I fought Kamui or many of the others I have faced. Calmly talk things out and usually you will find that your opponent will play give and take with you. Look I understand I hit you here and it would do this but you did do this to me and it would do this so instead of fighting like cats and dogs lets just compromise on us both taking some minor damage and move along. That kinda stuff works to many of your surprises (I suspect). IF you play nice things tend to go smoothly if you try to be a punk and rage and all you will usually just piss your opponent off and then they will not want to compromise at all.
-
For the most part that's avast majority that can rp with each other and everything is fine then there's also the opposite. Which is usually around bijuu fights or death matches.
-
I noticed that, I just like to fully explain the situation so people understand what we are dealing with.
The (one particular) issue with Dart was that he has 1 reset for Uchiha in game. That is all. He wants to rp with, reset wise:
4/4 Uchiha
4/4 Boil
4/4 Lava
I said I could give him Boil for free, 1 in Uchiha for the implant, and then 1 in Yoton from his actual reset, Dart said no he wants all of them he doesn't need any resets.
So we got Kay as a judge and we met in the midde so dart was rping with:
4/4 Boil
2/4 Uchiha
2/4 Yoton
Literally the very next day after that decision Dart pm's me saying "I am borrowing resets from Xia's alt now and will be using all 12 resets."
Like Shadow said not everyone is like Dart but some people are just going to up and ignore a judge. It's not the first time it has happened.
-
In which case I want to know what to do. Do we void the troll or what?
-
I noticed that, I just like to fully explain the situation so people understand what we are dealing with.
The (one particular) issue with Dart was that he has 1 reset for Uchiha in game. That is all. He wants to rp with, reset wise:
4/4 Uchiha
4/4 Boil
4/4 Lava
I said I could give him Boil for free, 1 in Uchiha for the implant, and then 1 in Yoton from his actual reset, Dart said no he wants all of them he doesn't need any resets.
So we got Kay as a judge and we met in the midde so dart was rping with:
4/4 Boil
2/4 Uchiha
2/4 Yoton
Literally the very next day after that decision Dart pm's me saying "I am borrowing resets from Xia's alt now and will be using all 12 resets."
Like Shadow said not everyone is like Dart but some people are just going to up and ignore a judge. It's not the first time it has happened.
That's when as a community we need to stand up and say "Hey, Buddy. No you are not." I'm not trying to trash Dart in anyway I'm just using this as an example. Nothing more nothing less.
-
I noticed that, I just like to fully explain the situation so people understand what we are dealing with.
The (one particular) issue with Dart was that he has 1 reset for Uchiha in game. That is all. He wants to rp with, reset wise:
4/4 Uchiha
4/4 Boil
4/4 Lava
I said I could give him Boil for free, 1 in Uchiha for the implant, and then 1 in Yoton from his actual reset, Dart said no he wants all of them he doesn't need any resets.
So we got Kay as a judge and we met in the midde so dart was rping with:
4/4 Boil
2/4 Uchiha
2/4 Yoton
Literally the very next day after that decision Dart pm's me saying "I am borrowing resets from Xia's alt now and will be using all 12 resets."
Like Shadow said not everyone is like Dart but some people are just going to up and ignore a judge. It's not the first time it has happened.
That's when as a community we need to stand up and say "Hey, Buddy. No you are not." I'm not trying to trash Dart in anyway I'm just using this as an example. Nothing more nothing less.
That is essentially what I did. I had just argued the whole thing out with Dart and just told him if he was going to straight up ignore a judge decision he will lose the 8 tails. So then he changed his bio into saying he was going with Kay's decision for the Kiri fight.
-
Back on topic guys.
Darkshinobi has been elected for Roleplay Judge/Mediator.
Continue.
-
Back on topic guys.
Darkshinobi has been elected for Roleplay Judge/Mediator.
Continue.
Hey, hey. MY topic. D:
I don't mind this being talked about here. >>
-
Back on topic guys.
Darkshinobi has been elected for Roleplay Judge/Mediator.
Continue.
Hey, hey. MY topic. D:
I don't mind this being talked about here. >>
I just want to see a pretty list compiled ;~;
I ELECT MYSELF. >____>
-
Back on topic guys.
Darkshinobi has been elected for Roleplay Judge/Mediator.
Continue.
I felt we were on topic as talking about this judge issue :p. You guys focus to much on this on topic issue if you ask me. But hey I'm one of those guys who loves random BS.
Anyways, as you said back to topic... I guess the only thing I have is if Dark will be the only one? I mean will there be a few more people chosen as well so people have more variety to pic from or whatnot.
-
Case One as the title is.
More will be put by myself or others. Dark just seemed very popular.
-
Case One as the title is.
More will be put by myself or others. Dark just seemed very popular.
I hope Dark-senpai notices me...
-
Case One as the title is.
More will be put by myself or others. Dark just seemed very popular.
He doesn't get a title or actual rank. xD
I hope Dark-senpai notices me...
-
Case One as the title is.
More will be put by myself or others. Dark just seemed very popular.
He is. I agree to this.
Back on topic guys.
Darkshinobi has been elected for Roleplay Judge/Mediator.
Continue.
I felt we were on topic as talking about this judge issue :p. You guys focus to much on this on topic issue if you ask me. But hey I'm one of those guys who loves random BS.
Anyways, as you said back to topic... I guess the only thing I have is if Dark will be the only one? I mean will there be a few more people chosen as well so people have more variety to pic from or whatnot.
Trust me if you look at the stats of my forum account all you'll see is spam section. I love random stuff. But I have to be a mod now ;-; and imo, discussing a past issue irrelevant to the person discussed at hand is off topic. (Just explaining my logic, carry on)
-
I highly doubt anyone will disagree, with good reason, as to why Sir Pink should not be a judge official guy.
-
I think an odd number of judges should be voted on, like 5 or 7. I'm thinking something along the lines of the supreme court for the sake of votes.
-
Dark all the way, easily >>
-
So should we compose a list of candidates and then vote on ho to consider or something?
-
I'd very much love being considered a judge. All participants of whichever dispute is in question needs to agree at that time, though.
I like the idea mentioned here and in the other thread where a list of volunteers to be a judge is made; when a serious infraction between two parties occurs, the parties agree on a judge or judges to preside over their fight.
And thanks everyone for the votes of confidence. ♥
-
Is that the 'q' for Shadow to make the next topic then?
I have to think it should be voted upon. That's just my opinion though. I like the idea of making a list and choosing x amount from it but whatever works.
-
Is that the 'q' for Shadow to make the next topic then?
I have to think it should be voted upon. That's just my opinion though. I like the idea of making a list and choosing x amount from it but whatever works.
Shadow is far too tired to do much of anything right now, yet I'm still up. I'm dumb.
-
The Raikage approves.
-
The Sabu approves.
Guys,
you should make me a judge
I'm super legit
Like a solid 7/10
-
The Sabu approves.
Guys,
you should make me a judge
I'm super legit
Like a solid 7/10
10/10 I agree he's a solid 7/10
-
The Sabu approves.
Guys,
you should make me a judge
I'm super legit
Like a solid 7/10
10/10 I agree he's a solid 7/10
Knowing your own Darkness is the best method for dealing with the Darknesses of other people.
I'm for it.
-
The Sabu approves.
Guys,
you should make me a judge
I'm super legit
Like a solid 7/10
10/10 I agree he's a solid 7/10
Knowing your own Darkness is the best method for dealing with the Darknesses of other people.
I'm for it.
Bumping this cause I love it.
-
Not in my opinion really, way I see it all it does is make you less of a hypocrite since you don't deny your faults anymore.
Not that I'm trying to secretly call dark a meanieface or things >> hush you.
-
We need a someone who doesn't claim techniques that no one else can get. >.>
-
I've always been down to be a judge, yet I've never been asked to judge any fights. I mean, I don't think that a set list of people who've volunteered to be judges or "GMs" would really stick because not everyone knows everyone, but maybe if someone made a page for certified judges on the wiki or something, people who want to volunteer could at least add themselves to such a list and it'd be there as a reference tool.
-
I vote we make a list for future reference, just in case someone needs an unbiased judge. :oops:
-
I vote we make a list for future reference, just in case someone needs an unbiased judge. :oops:
I really like this idea. Just a reference list of trusted RPers who people agree on so that anyone can come to the forum and check it out, and then have a choice as to who they ask, and if those people say no they have more people to ask.
-
So, what's going to happen here? I think it's a good idea to have this list of volunteers posted up somewhere. Should it be here on the forum? I suppose it would make sense to have it here rather than on the wiki, since this is where most RP related stuff occurs and the wiki is just for bios/claimed material essentially.
-
Here and on the Wikia. Sounds fine.