Shinobi Legends Forum
Roleplay => Village Square => Topic started by: Bocchiere on September 10, 2014, 05:44:54 AM
-
Ok, so I am fighting Xia in zone 8 for the 6 tails. He is about to go over the 14 day limit (11 days 6 hours as of this posting) for posting and makes it sound like he will not be able to post, literally saying he doesn't think he'll be able to continue this fight.
I'm willing to give Xia the extra week, I think it was, that you can claim once a year, if he would like to claim it, but I do not know if that would be enough time for him or not.
If he thinks it is and wants to opt for that then fine, but if he honestly does not think that would be enough time I would like him to just surrender the 6 tails rather than make me wait another week for no reason.
I am making this topic now because Xia is rarely on, and this way in details that I may be forgetting can be hammered out by the time he returns.
-
So which set of rules are we working with here? If this fight was started about 11 days ago, I'm presuming the current challenge ones, but just wanting to be sure before I carry on.
-
Started about 15 days ago, my last post was just 11 days ago.
Yeah though, we're using that you have to post every fortnight as a host. Precedence set with Nagato and Rinn shows that if you do that in a 1v1 fight like this your opponent gets the bijuu.
-
Xia has been busy a lot this year. Earlier when I went on my bijuu reform rampage I had already stated how he wasn't doing his host duties. (Posting every fortnight) For him specifically I made the 1 month 'get out of jail free' card. Where if something happened you could use it and not have to post as said. After that the flame died out and I assume that was his use of the card. I don't know.
Also to help with something popping up during fights in the current bijuu rules reform I suggested a once per bijuu fight addition of 1 week added on to the 14 days if an EMERGENCY happened. Total of 3 weeks to post.
Xia is a good rp'er, he knows his Naruto stuff, ect.
However his inactivity has been terrible. I say strip him. Until at a time his life becomes more free. I don't see his inactivity lessening. I may be wrong, but what we've seen so far...
-
Was the one week extension an agreed upon rule or not? I was going to offer it to Xia anyway, but like I said, if all it is going to do is make me wait 1 more week before stripping him I hope he'll just be a man and give up the slug.
I have nothing against Xia, mainly because he's never ever here, so he could be totally awful and I just wouldn't really know. :P
I knew Xia was inactive a lot of the time before we started our fight, which is why I suggested we just do a 1v1, because we'd never finish me coming to Kiri to fight him. But the fight literally has not even started yet and he is already unable to post. Considering his history of inactivity I'd say he should be stripped, especially since he apparently already used his one extension earlier, which I was unaware of.
-
Was the one week extension an agreed upon rule or not? I was going to offer it to Xia anyway, but like I said, if all it is going to do is make me wait 1 more week before stripping him I hope he'll just be a man and give up the slug.
I have nothing against Xia, mainly because he's never ever here, so he could be totally awful and I just wouldn't really know. :P
I knew Xia was inactive a lot of the time before we started our fight, which is why I suggested we just do a 1v1, because we'd never finish me coming to Kiri to fight him. But the fight literally has not even started yet and he is already unable to post. Considering his history of inactivity I'd say he should be stripped, especially since he apparently already used his one extension earlier, which I was unaware of.
When did he use the one extension that, to my knowledge, was only established roughly three months ago at best? Or are we talking about a different one?
Using the fortnight concept, I would suppose the beast would be up for stripping, but where would it go? Bocc, you already have a beast so you can't seal it in yourself if I recall correctly.
-
Was the one week extension an agreed upon rule or not? I was going to offer it to Xia anyway, but like I said, if all it is going to do is make me wait 1 more week before stripping him I hope he'll just be a man and give up the slug.
I have nothing against Xia, mainly because he's never ever here, so he could be totally awful and I just wouldn't really know. :P
I knew Xia was inactive a lot of the time before we started our fight, which is why I suggested we just do a 1v1, because we'd never finish me coming to Kiri to fight him. But the fight literally has not even started yet and he is already unable to post. Considering his history of inactivity I'd say he should be stripped, especially since he apparently already used his one extension earlier, which I was unaware of.
When did he use the one extension that, to my knowledge, was only established roughly three months ago at best? Or are we talking about a different one?
Using the fortnight concept, I would suppose the beast would be up for stripping, but where would it go? Bocc, you already have a beast so you can't seal it in yourself if I recall correctly.
I'm actually fighting him with my alt, but that doesn't change anything because he's an Edo zombie and unable to host bijuu for some reason. I suppose that was just an easy thing to ax because reasons.
Anyway I'd just get the slug in a jug then.
-
You're a pile of lifeless leaves and dirt, not a single whole, living organism, so of course its not gonna work. Only way it could be done is to pull a Minato.
-
Give him a week or give him a month...he'll still be mainly inactive. Life has hold of him at this time. Moving, his wife pregnant. (All things he made public) Xia won't be able to fulfill his host duties for the foreseen weeks/months.
They agreed upon the 2 week post rule. It's been 2 weeks so by that he would be stripped anyway. IF Bocc did add a week Xia said he'd still be unable to post. If Bocc gave Xia a month I still don't think he'd be able to post. (Due to the baby and such)
I could be wrong, but with what I've been able to gather. All roads lead to Bocc's alt getting it due to inactivity.
Edit:
Also the extra week to post has not been added as a rule nor has the extra month. I want both to become rules, but it's not just for me to decide.
-
You're a pile of lifeless leaves and dirt, not a single whole, living organism, so of course its not gonna work. Only way it could be done is to pull a Minato.
Yeah that'd be ridiculous
(https://dailyanimeart.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/jinchuriki_by_aleks_gold-d4h58ox.jpg)
-
You're a pile of lifeless leaves and dirt, not a single whole, living organism, so of course its not gonna work. Only way it could be done is to pull a Minato.
Yeah that'd be ridiculous
(https://dailyanimeart.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/jinchuriki_by_aleks_gold-d4h58ox.jpg)
It is ridiculous, which is why Edo's aren't permitted to be hosts. :P
And I guess strip is the answer then on this one. Any of the other inactive jinchs might as well start passing it on to village-mates who are more active, or I forsee this thread popping up a couple more times in the near future.
-
Whoa guys...
Maternity leave is a big deal.
What if someone else just finished the match for him?
Or what if someone contacted him on Face book to find out what he wants to do?
Or or or...
I think it is a good idea to talk to people before just doing things.
I am not saying inactivity is not a problem, no matter the reason. But it would be nice for Xia to be part of the decision making process here before everyone just decides how things are going to go down.
I don't think Mike trusts anyone else with his account. I'm not him though.
As for him taking part in this, I can only hope Bocc is talking to him when he can. Which I'd imagine is little due to him being inactive for days on end. Either way, he stated he won't be able to be active.
-
He gives me one sentence at a time, once or twice a week. The last message I sent him was basically, "Well you're going to be stripped if you can't post." so I don't know if he even knows about this.
I'm not even going to dignify how asinine Edo Tensei not being able to host bijuu is with a response. >>
The fact of the matter is that the rules says you get stripped if you cannot post every 14 days. It does not say, unless you have a good reason. Because it doesn't matter if you have a good reason, you still need to be around to post as a Jinchuriki, it is part of the responsibility you take on by becoming a host.
Considering how awful the current fights Akatsuki has for the remaining bijuu are, honestly, I would rather just strip Xia and get one easily, because I just don't want to even give it the chance to spiral out of control. Even if I did give him an extra week I don't think it would matter.
-
...I'm not even going to dignify how asinine Edo Tensei not being able to host bijuu is with a response. >>...
Well, considering they have limitless stamina and cannot die via normal means, combined with all of the standard abilities of a SL RPer, I think not being able to host a biju is in the least bit reasonable on the part of those not Edo'd. I mean, seriously, overkill much? XP
-
...I'm not even going to dignify how asinine Edo Tensei not being able to host bijuu is with a response. >>...
Well, considering they have limitless stamina and cannot die via normal means, combined with all of the standard abilities of a SL RPer, I think not being able to host a biju is in the least bit reasonable on the part of those not Edo'd. I mean, seriously, overkill much? XP
They get lots of chakra (a moot point) a fairly weak transformation compared to the Sage Mode 8 Gates combo anyone can use, and an extra elemental affinity. Ooooooooooo scary! D: Not.
-
...I'm not even going to dignify how asinine Edo Tensei not being able to host bijuu is with a response. >>...
Well, considering they have limitless stamina and cannot die via normal means, combined with all of the standard abilities of a SL RPer, I think not being able to host a biju is in the least bit reasonable on the part of those not Edo'd. I mean, seriously, overkill much? XP
They get lots of chakra (a moot point) a fairly weak transformation compared to the Sage Mode 8 Gates combo anyone can use, and an extra elemental affinity. Ooooooooooo scary! D: Not.
Lopped on with what they already have as a base character, yes, that is quite scary actually, to be adding on. The fact that they just don't die without some Yin-Yang intervention still just doesn't help that cause.
-
I just don't think it would be any harder to beat an Edo Tensei with a bijuu than one without one.
-
Getting off topic guys, if you must debate that edo rules, make a new thread.
Anyway, I say strip, but leave him alive. I got nothing against Xia, but he's too busy to be a host. So to be fair to Bocc, the beast should go to him, as the rules are quite clear on this matter. But to not totally screw Xia for having a life, don't kill his character. Seems fair to me.
-
Getting off topic guys, if you must debate that edo rules, make a new thread.
Anyway, I say strip, but leave him alive. I got nothing against Xia, but he's too busy to be a host. So to be fair to Bocc, the beast should go to him, as the rules are quite clear on this matter. But to not totally screw Xia for having a life, don't kill his character. Seems fair to me.
I didn't realize that killing his character was an option, given the circumstanes. Although it is a good idea to make that clear. 8)
I agree with Trev.
-
I was not going to kill his character anyway, so yes I agree. He has 2 hours to post before it is 14 days so Ill wait till time is officially up.
-
Alright so it has been 14 days so the 6 tails should be stripped from Xia an given to me, I don't think there is really any argument to the contrary, correct? Or should we wait for Xia to make a response to this topic first when, god knows when, he checks the forum?
-
Besides the comments about edo no one said no. Xia won't respond anytime soon. Kiri nin hate the forums. Good to go it seems.
-
Alright, 6 tails get. I'm locking this topic now, so if some Kiri nin want to raise a hullabaloo about this they'll have to make their own topic.