Yeah Nathan, I just want this system so I can steal every canon item without anyone being able to stop me, right. I want this system because it is simple, there is no wiggle room to abuse things, you fight or lose it, and like I said both of them is forcing people to rp. I'll use you're argument then. If you are gonna force people to rp somewhere so people can come hunt them then why not just allow people to challenge them? You didn't address my point of me just bringing gangs of people in to beat up each person. There is no way to stop that, if Enishi or someone is gonna have to wander through one of the zones then what is stopping me and 6 of my friends from just happening to wander in and attack him? I've met every SSM member with a sword except Enishi and Mioku, fyi, and since Rakudo has like 4 now that's all that really matters. What about things like the Totsuka Sword? Mioku never used it, so no one knows about it, even if he gets stripped and it gets given to someone else what is that going to change? The new person can choose to never use it and it will be as inaccesable as it ever was because no one will know about it.
THE POINT IS
Both of ideas are forcing people to rp but Nathan's idea is too vague at this time, which means people are going to abuse it and going to cause problems and judges are going to be called and it is going to be a hassle. It would require way more input to work properly.