It was not even a matter of playing favorites. I don't even know the other guy. I'm only being fair in this regard, because it's a first come first serve AFTER the grace period. If you ask me during my peace and quiet then of course I'm not going to reply because, to me, it's not fair to accept a challenge beforehand when people are waiting till my grace period ends. I thought we resolved the issue but apparently not if you're posting this.
Thank you Athos, though, for seeing my point. I don't see the issue with this. This is fair.
The entirety of what you said has been contradicted with the Pm's I pasted above,
"---Original Message from Deathstroke(2015-08-12 01:46:13)---
Before she was viable to be challenged I know, she counted it anyway. I know you were not on as I always recognize your name on the list due to the similar color scheme. I asked her for no reason if she had any other challengers at the time and she said no. So I would assume it was before you leveled yours."
He challenged you before the grace period was up, and you accepted it, the Proof is in the pudding. If it was about fairness, and he actually waited till the grace period was over, and then sent you a challenge, that'd be cool but the fact of the matter is. I sent you a challenge before the grace period was over, you ignored it, he sent you one before the grace period was over, you accepted.