Forgive me if this was mentioned as I only read some of the comments on the first page, but wouldn't be easier if the GMs that active people that are periodically chosen. This is what I mean....
Neji can release a list of top 20 (or top 30) most active people on SL in the past 6 months. We vote for 4 people from that list to be GMs for 3 or 4 months. Then at the end of their term, Neji releases another list of most active SL members and again, we choose 4 from that list.
Because in the end, you can choose whoever you want as GM but if you're not going to be active long, then you will just encounter the same problem over and over again. At least this way, you are guarantee a set of active GMs.
Now, is there a chance that top active people are not even RPers (you know, people who come to only chat and/or use turns)? Of course, but then we have a short RP guide that they can read (or someone can make RP guidelines that GMs will use to judge a post). But for now, let's assume the odds of that happening are nearly 0%. >.>
This idea assumes that Neji can find out who is the most active members on SL and release that information. And of course, this is a basic idea that needs more details but we can all talk about that later if the majority agrees to this idea. >.>
#ShinobiDemocracy